Our Privacy/Cookie Policy contains detailed information about the types of cookies & related technology on our site, and some ways to opt out. By using the site, you agree to the uses of cookies and other technology as outlined in our Policy, and to our Terms of Use.


I Secretly Resented Breastfeeding

Photograph by Getty Images

At first, breastfeeding hurt.

My nipples were chafed and seemingly frozen into an erect position, like a porn star ready for her close-up. My milk leaked down my side in the rare moments I was sleeping, leaving me sticky and slightly sour-smelling. By the time it stopped hurting and we got our latch figured out, my newborn had started cluster feeding. Each night, my son kept me pinned to the couch for hours. I was exhausted, bored and quite literally, drained.

I knew breastfeeding was the healthiest choice for my kids. I had always planned to do it, and I was fortunate not to have any issues that prevented me from nursing.

But I didn't like it.

RELATED: 7 Reasons You Should Seriously Consider Midwives

While I was amazed and proud that my body could actually make milk for my son, I didn't feel like a milk-fountain goddess. Instead, I felt like the primary parent, the food source, the pacifier. It didn't help that I had postpartum depression, or that my son wanted to nurse every half hour for the first several months of his life.

I wish I'd heard from other moms who, like me, nursed out of a sense of responsibility but came to dislike it.

It was also confusing. It's taboo to admit, but my super-sensitive nipples had always been purely sexual for me. While nursing was at first uncomfortable, I later sometimes felt a hint of arousal while breastfeeding. This was confusing at best—and creepy at worst. A quick Google session suggested that Mother Nature had designed our nipples to be sensitive so that breastfeeding would be pleasurable, and something women would want to do to ensure their babies wouldn't starve in the days before formula was an option. I found it slightly comforting that I wasn't just a big perv, but I also wondered why Mother Nature couldn't have designed our bodies so the milk could come from a more neutral body part, like perhaps an elbow.

Breastfeeding made me feel so tethered. Emotionally and mentally, I gave my little boy my all. I surrendered into attachment parenting, putting my own needs last as my son's temperament seemed to demand. Co-sleeping was the only way I could string together sleep, babywearing was the only way I could get anything done, and nursing seemed to be the only way to sooth my colicky boy. Having my body on constant offer was taxing.

And yet, we continued.

We continued through the "distracted nursing" stage, when it seemed like my son was trying to pull my nipple into the other room with him. We even continued through a nasty biting stage.

As my son got older and ate more and more solid food, I was able to cut down on the frequent nursing. But he didn't surrender easily, and I soon found myself nursing a toddler.

It was just after he turned 2 that I realized I was done.

After nine months of pregnancy and 26 months of nursing, I was beyond ready to have my body back to myself. Breastfeeding a toddler just didn't feel right any more. I began to dread nursing; the moment my son came home from preschool and immediately demanded, "Milt! Milt!" I knew it was his way of connecting with me after several hours apart, but I also knew that resenting our breastfeeding relationship while continuing to do it wasn't sustainable. And as a toddler instead of a newborn, nursing was no longer a need for my son—it was a want.

RELATED: 10 Things That Make It Hard for Breastfeeding Mothers

Over the course of several weeks, I weaned him. He protested, and it wasn't easy. But I was so ready to have my body back.

Looking back, I wonder if I would've been able to embrace breastfeeding more if I'd had some balance in the early months and years, if I'd had more breaks from my son, or if I'd been better rested. I don't regret the 26 months of breastfeeding my son; it was simply the first of many things that, as a parent, I did for my child at my own discomfort.

But I wish I'd heard from other moms who, like me, nursed out of a sense of responsibility but came to dislike it. I wish someone had told me that breastfeeding isn't always the sweet oxytocinfest that we think it will be—it's sometimes annoying, confusing or suffocating.

More from baby