Our Privacy/Cookie Policy contains detailed information about the types of cookies & related technology on our site, and some ways to opt out. By using the site, you agree to the uses of cookies and other technology as outlined in our Policy, and to our Terms of Use.


I Can't Stop Thinking About the Baby That Might Have Been

Photograph by Twenty20

I'm not sure why I took an ovulation predictor test. My doctor had suggested last year that I go off birth control because I'm approaching menopausal age. Three months after I stopped taking the pill, I had all of the classic ovulation symptoms and an old ovulation predictor kit lying around, so why not? The second line on the test confirmed what I already knew.

There were a couple of years when a positive OPK was something I wished for. After three miscarriages, every month was a big question mark about whether I'd get pregnant. But now my sons are 8 and 6, and those emotionally charged years are behind me. Our family is complete.

I told my husband I was ovulating and he joked that we should try for another baby. My initial reaction was, "Stay away from me!" I even teased that I would have to move out because I couldn't handle him and three kids.

But later that night, when the house was quiet and everyone else was asleep, I felt a little sad. I couldn't stop thinking about the baby that might have been—would it have been the little sister our boys have occasionally asked for? Girl or boy, my 6-year-old wouldn't be the baby anymore. He might like that, since he's already starting to break away from my hugs.

It's the first time I really acknowledged that this really is it, this is as big as our family will get.

I daydreamed about what it would be like to have a third child. I even did the math and calculated a potential due date. It would be easy to take care of an infant while my older kids were in school (at least compared to having two under 2). I could probably manage to work at least part-time while the baby napped, and after school, I'd have two eager helpers to hold, feed and entertain the baby while I made dinner.

Then I thought about the things I might have to give up: my current workload, for sure. And family vacations would be put on hold for a little bit. I'd need a bigger vehicle to accommodate a car seat and two growing boys. Sleep—something that I finally get (almost) enough of—would once again be a thing of the past. Money would get a little tighter as we dealt with the costs of diapers and childcare once again.

But to be honest, the downside of having a third child didn’t seem to be all that bad. The disruption would be an adjustment, but it would be temporary. And yet, I knew the odds were slim that it would work out even if I decided to try.

Having experienced multiple miscarriages, I know what it’s like to say goodbye to babies that weren’t meant to be. At the time, I didn’t know what it was like to be a mother. Now I know everything I’m missing by not having another baby. This is the first time I’ve really considered all of the joys of motherhood and said goodbye to a baby that might have been. It's the first time I really acknowledged that this really is it, this is as big as our family will get, and there will definitely be no more babies growing inside me.

I don't know why I cried when my period started. I’m thrilled with my two growing boys, especially with everything I went through waiting and wondering if I would ever be a mother. I really don't want to have another child. But the tears came anyway, a reminder that some things just aren’t meant to be—whether we know if we want them or not.

More from baby