Our Privacy/Cookie Policy contains detailed information about the types of cookies & related technology on our site, and some ways to opt out. By using the site, you agree to the uses of cookies and other technology as outlined in our Policy, and to our Terms of Use.


5 Nice Ways to Lie About a Dead Pet

Eight years ago, I was at a fundraiser in the Pacific Palisades at the home of the fab director David O'Russell ("American Hustle," "Silver Linings Playbook") with my then 2-and-a-half-year-old. A name drop, I know, but it's relevant, because I'm not sure I would have been suckered into what happened next if I wasn't such a diehard fan. Mr. O'Russell's then wife, Janet, greeted us as soon as we came to the door. Suspecting Gabriel would be bored after polishing off a handful of cookies, she quickly whisked us through the master bedroom and into the bathroom where she had—wait for it—two tiny bunnies.

"I bought them for David, but it turns out he can't stand them," she told us, as Gabriel watched the furry balls leaping over wet towels.

"They need a home with kids. I'll give you a cage and food for a year. David will be so happy to know they went to such a nice family."

Half an hour later, we were heading east on Sunset Boulevard with a bunny cage and a trunk filled with hay pellets. "You did what?" Tod, my husband asked me, as Gabriel stared through the wire mesh at his new friends in the back seat.

The bunnies lived in the breakfast nook for a month, until they were big enough to move to a cage on stilts in the back yard. Gabriel named them Hakuna and Matata from "The Lion King." He would take them out, put them in his lap and pet them daily. I gave them carrot tops and lettuce leaves to snack on. Everyone loved watching them jump around the yard. Until one day, I went in the house to put Gabriel down for his nap while they were getting their exercise. When I came back, out Matata was lying on her side in the grass.

Not breathing.

A little dog had snuck in under our fence and did what dogs do to bunny rabbits. It was a Medea-like moment for me. I literally fell to my knees next to her and wept. For about two minutes. Then I realized I hadn't thought through the death part of a household pet and had no interest in explaining mortality to a post-nap toddler.

RELATED: Teaching Kids to Say Good-Bye to a Pet

It was 4 o'clock on a Sunday afternoon. I remember, because I immediately started calling around to pet stores in search of a black and white, floppy eared bunny rabbit. In the moment, nothing made sense to me other than replacing the rabbit with a close enough facsimile and praying Gabriel went with it. By the time I found one, I had 20 minutes to get to the store before it closed, which I did. My husband took Matata away (to this day I don't know to where) and the new bunny was in the cage faster than you can say, "Mommy dodged a grief bullet."

Since then, I've realized there are other ways to handle the death of a family pet, particularly if your child is under the age of 5. After that, you're pretty much in for a talk about the cycle of life. Which, according to anyone who knows anything about children, you should keep very simple: Only answer the questions they ask. For those first few innocent years, here are a few options for handling this family upheaval. The first three work best when the child isn't around for the end.

If you just can't bear to witness your child's broken heart, or if you need to distract them immediately after, call Grandma and/or Grandpa and have them take your child out for ice cream.

1. The Switcheroo

Still my personal favorite, it involves replacing the small animal/fish before your child notices. Despite experts agreeing that you should never lie to your child, this remains No. 1 for not prematurely overwhelming your baby with the seven stages of grief.

2. Call of Duty

If you go with No. 1, and your toddler figures it out, congratulate yourself for having a very bright child. In this case, explain to your tiny genius that the new friend is Cutey Pie's sister or brother and that the Mommy needed Cutey Pie back. But she promises his sibling is just as lovable.

3. Play the exhaustion card.

Explain to your child that Cutey Pie was exhausted from so much playing all the time (and not eating right—why not use it as an opportunity to land the importance of a well-balanced diet?) and needed to go somewhere to rest for a while ... maybe a long while. Then promise to take them out and get them a more energetic pet ASAP. Note: If your child brings it up again, you might also have to draft a short letter from the director of the small-pet rest home.

4. Let the grandparents do it.

If you just can't bear to witness your child's broken heart, or if you need to distract them immediately after, call Grandma and/or Grandpa and have them take your child out for ice cream. With great wisdom (and great amounts of sugar) in their arsenal, Nanny and Poppa can soften the blow by telling stories about the "old country" and all the pets they've loved and lost. Then, they order their grandchild a much deserved second scoop and give them hugs. The only downside? If it happens more than once, your child might start to associate ice cream with death. This will not work well if Grandpa was in the military and has more of a "Suck it up, pets die, just be glad it wasn't your mother," sensibility. If that's the case, stick with No. 1.

5. Go with the fake stuff.

To avoid ever having to face this again, take your little buddy to the store and fill up a cart with stuffed versions of all shapes, sizes, textures and sounds of the little varmint. And never buy a living pet again.

RELATED: What to do When Grandparents Undermine Parents' Authority

I'm kidding! Pets are awesome! Who else wags their tail when they see me? And, despite the fact that I am not willing to let go of avoiding the death conversation with the preschool set, I do respect the expert opinion not to tell your child that the creature went "to sleep" or that you had to have the pet "put to sleep"—or any connection to sleep and death. Children have enough things swirling around in their minds at bedtime. No one wants kids thinking that they could possibly fall asleep forever if they close they eyes at sleep time.

More from kids