When: Circa 1996
So What Happened? The "Wild" star is now happily married to talent agent Jim Toth, and Mark Wahlberg is married to longtime love Rhea Durham. But back in the day when Reese Witherspoon starred in the movie "Fear" opposite Wahlberg, the two were an item. In the movie, Wahlberg shows his darker side and his character becomes obsessed with Witherspoon's character. Let's hope life didn't imitate art.