On a typical Saturday in Santa Fe, N.M., 18-year-old
Malina Simard-Halm can be found catching up on TV shows, watching movies with
her family or, when she’s feeling adventurous, rock climbing. With dreams
of a grand future as she is set to begin her freshman year at Yale, who
wouldn’t smile as Malina walks by, her beauty and youth a gentle reminder of
those days when life seemed limitless?
There is one woman who probably wouldn’t smile at the sight
of Malina and all of the possibilities that lay before her. This woman might
shake her head, determining that Malina is the exception and not the rule. Jennifer Lahl, a former critical care
nurse, believes that the process that helped to create
Malina’s life should be regulated and even banned.
Malina is the product of gestational surrogacy, a process
during which a woman carries a biologically unrelated child that is conceived through in vitro
fertilization and nurtured in her womb
until birth. Gestational surrogacy is different from traditional surrogacy in
that traditional surrogates used their own eggs and were biologically related
to the child they gave birth to.
Lahl, the founder of The Center for Bioethics and Cultural
Network, is a very vocal detractor of surrogacy and expresses her
disapproval in three films, including "Eggsploitation" (2010) and "Anonymous
Father’s Day" (2011). Both films criticize assisted reproductive technology and IVF, the process that successfully produced Louise Brown, the world’s first “test tube baby” in 1978.
Lahl’s latest film released this year, "Breeder: A Sub Class of Women?" documents four women who have had harmful experiences with surrogacy. Lahl goes on to claim
that gestational surrogacy breaks natural mother-child bonds and is a tool for the wealthy to subjugate women.
'What gives this woman the right to disallow couples from ever attaining their dream?'
“I would not have been born without surrogacy,” Malina, shares
softly. “My parents fought for nearly a decade to have me, and it was surrogacy
that came through. Proponents that believe that surrogacy should be stripped
away scare and madden me.”
Malina’s two fathers, Will and Marcellin, are a couple in
New Mexico who had one goal that seemed far-reaching: to complete their family
by having a child. Malina is their life’s dream come true.
“What gives this
woman the right to disallow couples from ever attaining their dream?” Malina
asks. “This woman epitomizes those who misunderstand our families. She says, ‘It’s
all about adults.’ Surrogacy is simply not just about adults or wants or
needs: It is about establishing something that is so powerful and so
fundamental to our humanity. To disallow someone the right to family is
despicable to me.”
Malina Simard-Halm (right), born through gestational surrogacy, shares how surrogacy helped her fathers complete their family. Image via Malina Simard-Halm/Twitter
Although one might argue that creating a family isn’t a "right," it is a mission that Growing Generations, a surrogacy and egg donation
facility with offices in Los Angeles and New York has undertaken with blooming
success. Since opening its doors in 2006, Growing Generations has assisted in
creating more than 1,000 bundles of joy, including Malina.
In "Breeders," Lahl reduces the process by which youth like Malina was
conceived to a mere cash transaction, a baby-buying operation, while pointing out emotional and physical
harms are often by-products of assisted reproduction.
Dr. Gilbert Mottla of Shady Grove Fertility recognizes
that the process of in vitro fertilization isn’t perfect, but recent advances
have lowered the rate at which mistakes occur. “Negative experiences in the
context of being a gestational carrier are quite rare,” Mottla explains. “Comprehensive
medical and psychologic screening of gestational carriers and intended parents
greatly minimize complications. Single embryo transfers performed for GCs
nearly eliminate the risk of twins and multiple pregnancies, helping to
minimize medical complications for both the carrier and child.”
Lahl's argument that surrogacy turns children into commodities and degrades women treats such "breeding" as a shame, while Mottla affirms these women, offering them an honor that
is equated with a heroic act.
'There is a unique sense of joy that comes with giving the gift of parenthood.'
“Prospective parents should know there is a unique
relationship with a gestational carrier,” he says. “This woman has accepted the
risks of being pregnant, the discomfort of being pregnant to enable the couple to
have a baby by her bringing a new life in the world. The gestational carrier is
typically a young mother herself and should be seen and respected for the
individual she is and the responsibilities she has taken on.”
As 33-year-old Abby Estwick reflects back on her time as a
gestational carrier, she reveals that she indeed took risks that complicated
her health and lifestyle even after the child was born, yet she doesn’t believe
the long term effects are as harmful as Lahl proclaims.
“My surrogacy went well,” Estwick shares. “I had a couple
that I came to adore and we truly banded together through each hurdle we were
After being matched with a couple and spending time with
them to ensure that this commitment would be ideal for everyone involved,
Estwick’s first cycle of in vitro failed to implant, which was emotionally distressing.
She didn’t want to fail the couple who had waited a very long time to have a
“My second cycle worked and I was pregnant with twins,”
Estwick shares and smiles. “I was placed on bed rest and eventually gave birth
to two twin boys at 28 weeks. It was difficult. I initially did feel like my
body failed me. I wanted to carry the babies to term. However, the support,
love and gratitude that their parents gave to me during that time was
After the birth of the twins, Estwick continued her
connection to the parents by offering her breast milk to aid in the twins’ growth
and nutritional needs. Over a decade later, she and the couple she conceived
for are still friends.
“There is a unique sense of joy that comes with giving the
gift of parenthood,” Estwick shares. “The friendship forged from that experience
is one I have grown to revere. I spent my past Mother’s Day with my friends and
all of our children. I gave them sons and they gave me a lasting friendship.”